Four logicians (A, B, C, and D) have fixed identities: two always tell the truth, and two always lie. You ask A: "Is B a liar?" A whispers. You ask B: "What did A just say?" B replies: "A said that C is a liar." D immediately says: "Do not believe him, B is lying!" Based strictly on this information, which statement can be deduced with absolute certainty?
- B and D have opposite identities
- A is a truth-teller
- D is a truth-teller
- None of these
Explanation
D's statement directly concerns whether B is lying.
If D tells the truth, B lies; if D lies, B tells the truth.
Therefore, B and D must have opposite identities.
Verified & Updated
Related MCQs
- 0° (The premise contains a topographic falsehood; tracks must be parallel)
- 90° (They are perfectly perpendicular)
- 60°
- None of these
اس سوال کو وضاحت کے ساتھ پڑھیں
- B and D have opposite identities
- A is a truth-teller
- D is a truth-teller
- None of these
اس سوال کو وضاحت کے ساتھ پڑھیں
- The relationship is structurally impossible under bilateral pedigree constraints.
- They are the exact same individual.
- The scholar is the maternal uncle of the cousin.
- None of these
اس سوال کو وضاحت کے ساتھ پڑھیں
- San Marino
- Vatican City
- Campione d'Italia
- None of these
اس سوال کو وضاحت کے ساتھ پڑھیں
- 36
- 100
- 96
- None of these